• We’re Back – Thanks for Your Patience! We’re thrilled to welcome you back! After some time offline, our site is up and running again, though you may experience occasional instability as we work through the final steps of restoring full functionality. Your understanding and support mean the world to us – thank you for sticking with us through this!
  • Email notifications are being sent but may be blocked by spam filters. If you don’t receive an expected email, please check your spam folder.

Stove Coleman Oven - Cast Iron Griddle!

Jim Carter said:
I didn't even know they made one without handles. That could come in handy for many uses.
Click to expand...

Ya, they've had a handful of them over the years of varying sizes, but I had originally given up on finding one. I was surprised late last year to find that not only were they making them again, but that they were making one that seemed like a perfect fit for the Coleman oven. So, I gambled and bought one...the measurements were correct, and now we have pizza every time we camp!
 
Jim Carter said:
I didn't even know they made one without handles. That could come in handy for many uses.
Click to expand...

You thinking what I'm thinking? Barbarian rules Frizbee!!!

I used to like lodge --- but the stuff I've seen coming from them recently is very rough, and the iron pitted. Takes a lot of work to get a working carbon layer. BTW, Use beeswax -- it's amazing! Just like oil - wipe on a thin layer on a hot surface --- a pound lasts us a year...its been covered here in the forums.
 
Sweeney said:
You thinking what I'm thinking? Barbarian rules Frizbee!!!

I used to like lodge --- but the stuff I've seen coming from them recently is very rough, and the iron pitted. Takes a lot of work to get a working carbon layer. BTW, Use beeswax -- it's amazing! Just like oil - wipe on a thin layer on a hot surface --- a pound lasts us a year...its been covered here in the forums.
Click to expand...

I like the Barbarian Frisbee idea. Might be fun to machine some spikes into the edges. New business idea for the current era: Apocalypse Cast Iron! Having flashbacks to the Road Warrior movie from the early 80's...

Even with the rougher texture, I agree...it's different now. The Lodge stuff is still fine with a PROPER patina...it does take a little extra treatment, though. And bacon. Lots and lots of bacon :). Doesn't take much to sand the interior surface down, though, if it's really an issue. I'm happy to do that if it means I can buy an American-made product. If you ever get the chance, there is a National Cornbread Festival in South Pittsburg, Tennessee in the spring. Besides having absolutely *mind-blowing* cornbread, it also happens to be the home of the Lodge factory...and the festival is the only time they open the factory up for tours. It was REALLY cool seeing how everything is manufactured.
 
Mike & Lisa said:
I like the Barbarian Frisbee idea. Might be fun to machine some spikes into the edges. New business idea for the current era: Apocalypse Cast Iron! Having flashbacks to the Road Warrior movie from the early 80's...

Even with the rougher texture, I agree...it's different now. The Lodge stuff is still fine with a PROPER patina...it does take a little extra treatment, though. And bacon. Lots and lots of bacon :). Doesn't take much to sand the interior surface down, though, if it's really an issue. I'm happy to do that if it means I can buy an American-made product. If you ever get the chance, there is a National Cornbread Festival in South Pittsburg, Tennessee in the spring. Besides having absolutely *mind-blowing* cornbread, it also happens to be the home of the Lodge factory...and the festival is the only time they open the factory up for tours. It was REALLY cool seeing how everything is manufactured.
Click to expand...

You know what goes good with bacon? More bacon! Pre--covid we were very keto -- lost about 100 pounds eating bacon & eggs, steak, fish, avacado....love it!

I do like the american made aspect of lodge as well. We've driven past the plant many times, never stopped beucase I'm sure the factory store looks pretty much like my kitechen. And I like the fact theirs is still affordable. We have looked at some of the new bands and while they are much higher qulity -- you'll pay for it.

The last cast I bought, I did sand -- maybe with a an agressive disk. I found a lot of pits and unevenness hidden under the factory "seasoning" --- migh be my damage, I don't know. I found some rust forming under the seasoning of my griddle .... I suspect I'll be re-doing that one.

You say when you sanded yours it wasn't grainy and pitted? Did you hand sand or use a tool?
 
  • Like
Reactions: M&L
Sweeney said:
You say when you sanded yours it wasn't grainy and pitted? Did you hand sand or use a tool?
Click to expand...

I don't recall excessive graininess or pitting. I started with sandpaper, then fiddled with a wooden block and some grit I had laying around from an old telescope mirror project from years ago, then finally broke out the Dremel which made things move along quickly!
 
I think I may have used an agressive paper --- I saw a video and used the same tool he used, his worked -- mine was a disaster.

think I'll stick to hand sanding when I need to readdress this issue
 
  • Like
Reactions: M&L
Long Truong said:
We also bought an Lodge Grill/Griddle and it nestles very well on top of the stove: https://www.amazon.com/Lodge-Revers...d/dp/B002CMLTXG/ref=psdc_289821_t2_B00I4XNEE4
Click to expand...

I have the one with built in handles... much easier to clean and get on/off the stove and fits perfectly.. but it is a few pounds heavier...

https://www.amazon.com/Lodge-Pro-Grid-Griddle-Reversible-Easy-Grip/dp/B00008GKDQ/ref=sr_1_2?crid=BSHSE3YWSO2J&keywords=lodge+griddle&qid=1649517887&s=home-garden&sprefix=lodge+griddle,garden,80&sr=1-2
 
Mike & Lisa said:
Putting this out there for anyone using the Coleman Oven accessory that fits on top of the stove in the galley. Lodge makes a 9.25-inch griddle that fits perfectly inside. We use the griddle for making pizza while camping (see attached photo). Highly, highly recommend!

Link: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00I4XNEE4
Click to expand...
In your mouth watering picture, is that a wood pizza peel under your griddle? Are you using that to remove the no handle griddle from the oven, or the pot holder in the back round, or is there like a lid lifter to pull it from the oven?
 
dustinp said:
In your mouth watering picture, is that a wood pizza peel under your griddle? Are you using that to remove the no handle griddle from the oven, or the pot holder in the back round, or is there like a lid lifter to pull it from the oven?
Click to expand...

Great question. The pizza is sitting on the (very hot) cast iron griddle, and the griddle is sitting on an olivewood cutting board that we keep with the trailer. The reasons we're using the cutting board here are to a.) hold and transfer the HOT griddle to the side table after taking it out of the oven (we put the pizza here briefly for the photo), and b.) keep the keep the griddle from scratching up the side table surface (which was unprotected at the time). The pot holder (which was made by my mother-in-law and matches our homemade quilt inside the cabin!) is used to grab the edge of the griddle and pull it out of the oven and onto the cutting board.
 
Mike & Lisa said:
Great question. The pizza is sitting on the (very hot) cast iron griddle, and the griddle is sitting on an olivewood cutting board that we keep with the trailer. The reasons we're using the cutting board here are to a.) hold and transfer the HOT griddle to the side table after taking it out of the oven (we put the pizza here briefly for the photo), and b.) keep the keep the griddle from scratching up the side table surface (which was unprotected at the time). The pot holder (which was made by my mother-in-law and matches our homemade quilt inside the cabin!) is used to grab the edge of the griddle and pull it out of the oven and onto the cutting board.
Click to expand...
Great answer
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top